Cisco Systems’ Financial Analysis (2008 to 2012)

 

Overview

Abstract

About Cisco Systems

Analytical objectives

Strategic Analysis

Analyzing the financial growth of the company

Margin Analysis

Economic Context Analysis

Financial Ratios Analysis

Measuring Performance

Measuring Efficiency

Measuring Risk

Measuring Liquidity

References

Appendix

 

Abstract

 

This essay aims to analyze and discuss Cisco Systems’ financial results over the last 5 years. It starts with a statement of the principal stakeholder group for whom the analysis is done and their likely information needs.

Then, it will analyze the strategic issues facing the company. And finally, analysis of Cisco’s current financial position and its ability to meet the challenges.

About Cisco Systems

 

CISCO SYSTEMS INC. is the worldwide leader in networking for the Internet.

 

The company was founded in 1984 by two computer scientists from Stanford University seeking an easier way to connect different types of computer systems.

 

Cisco Systems shipped its first product in 1986 and is now a multi-national corporation, with over 72,000 employees in more than 115 countries. Today, Cisco solutions are the networking foundations for service providers, small to medium business and enterprise customers which includes corporations, government agencies, utilities and educational institutions.

 

Cisco’s networking solutions connect people, computing devices and computer networks, allowing people to access or transfer information without regard to differences in time, place or type of computer system.

 

Cisco continues to grow through internal development, acquisitions, their global partnerships, and cross-functional teamwork. One area of their differentiated strategy includes a goal of growing each product category in their advanced technologies to capture $1 billion-plus in annual revenue and the number-one market position (Chambers 2008).

 

Cisco does not only provide networking products, but it build complete end to end solutions and architectures starting from basic routing and switching, to security, wireless, collaboration, data centers and video solutions.

Analytical objectives:

 

It’s important to point that this essay aims to analyze Cisco System’s financial position to shareholders. Information provided in this essay is to help shareholders in their decision-making whether to buy, sell or hold their shares.

Strategic Analysis

 

Cisco is a leading company in the IT industry; it’s crucial to the financial study to do strategic analysis for Cisco’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. This essay will use SWOT analysis framework to do so.

 

Image

As a summary for the above analysis, the following strategic issues may affect Cisco’s financial results in the coming period:

  1. Maintaining the market-share leadership needs regular improvements in the current products, which will affect the cost of sale.
  2. Innovating new products to capture market transition will affect the R&D budget and will affect the gross margins.
  3. The global political instability may affect the operating costs and hence the gross margins
  4. The global economic contexts instability “Tax, exchange rates and inflation rates…etc.” will affect the gross margins.
  5. Supply chain issues inside Cisco has to be solved, otherwise it may affect operating costs and hence the gross margins.

Analyzing the financial growth of the company:

 

It’s very clear from the below Income Statement comparison for the last five years that Cisco is well growing there revenue throughout the last 4 years.  It also shows how Cisco was able to optimize their operating costs in 2012 and reduce it by 4%.

Cisco sell Products and Services, and they consider them as two separate organizations, that’s why it’s shown as two line items in the income statement. It’s clear that the Products organization generates more revenue, while Services organization is growing faster.

 

2012 Variance 2011 Variance 2010 Variance 2009 Variance 2008
Net sales
Product $36,326 5% $34,526 6% $32,420 11% $29,131 -12% $33,099
Services $9,735 12% $8,692 14% $7,620 9% $6,986 8% $6,441
Total Net Sales $46,061 7% $43,218 8% $40,040 11% $36,117 -9% $39,540
Cost Of Sales
Product $14,505 6% $13,647 17% $11,620 11% $10,481 -10% $11,660
Services $3,347 10% $3,035 9% $2,777 9% $2,542 0% $2,534
Total Cost Of Sales $17,852 7% $16,682 16% $14,397 11% $13,023 -8% $14,194
Gross Margin $28,209 6% $26,536 3% $25,643 11% $23,094 -9% $25,346
 
Operating Expenses
Research and Development $5,488 -6% $5,823 10% $5,273 1% $5,208 -2% $5,325
Sales and Marketing $9,647 -2% $9,812 12% $8,782 5% $8,403 -3% $8,690
General and Administration $2,322 22% $1,908 -1% $1,933 24% $1,565 13% $1,387
Amortization Of Purchased Intangible Assets $383 -26% $520 6% $491 -8% $533 7% $499
Restructuring And Other Charges $304 -62% $799 N/A $- $63 2000% $3
Total Operating Expenses $18,144 -4% $18,862 14% $16,479 4% $15,772 -1% $15,904
Operating Income
Interest Income $650 1% $641 1% $635 27% $499 -39% $824
Interest Expense $596 -5% $628 1% $623 387% $128 1064% $11
Other Income, net $40 -71% $138 -42% $239 N/A $- $-
Total Operating Income $94 -38% $151 -40% $251 -32% $371 -54% $813
INCOME BEFORE PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES $10,159 30% $7,825 -17% $9,415 22% $7,693 -25% $10,255
 
Provision For Income Taxes $2,118 59% $1,335 -19% $1,648 6% $1,559 -29% $2,203
NET INCOME $8,041 24% $6,490 -16% $7,767 27% $6,134 -24% $8,052
Net Income Per Share
Basic $1.50 28% $1.17 -14% $1.36 30% $1.05 -22% $1.35
Diluted $1.49 27% $1.17 -12% $1.33 27% $1.05 -20% $1.31
Shares Used In Per-Share Calculation
Basic 5,370 -3% 5,529.00 -4% 5,732 -2% 5,828 -3% 5,986.00
Diluted 5,404 -3% 5,563.00 -5% 5,848 0% 5,857 -5% 6,163.00
Cash Dividends Declared Per Common Share $0.28 133% $0.12 N/A $- $- $-

 

Table 1. Cisco Income Statement Comparison

 

 

Margin Analysis:

 

Marginal analysis is an important way for decision-making in the business world. Marginal analysis measures the additional benefits of one production activity versus its costs. This analysis can help the shareholder to understand whether an activity is profitable and thus make a decision based on that information.

The following margin ratios give a clue as to the financial structure of the business and its exposure to business risk.

Image

Figure 1. Cisco Margin Analysis

 

The above graph “Figure 1” shows that there’s a slight improvement in the different profit margins in 2012 than in 2011, which reflect general enhancements and cost optimizations done in that year, but it also shows the economy effect on the company profit margins, as it’s lower than what it had in 2008 and 2010.

Decreasing gross profit margins is due to the higher discounts given for the products and services as a response to the economy slow down and the increased competition.

Cisco started to distribute dividends in 2011, which decreased the retained profit margins as shown in the graph.

Economic Context Analysis:

 

As Cisco Systems part of the wider economy, both contribute to and is affected by the prevailing economic conditions. A significant influence upon the performance of Cisco is the general level of economic activity, exchange rates, taxation, interest rates, and inflation rates.

Cisco is operating in around 117 countries, which make it difficult to provide comprehensive economic context analysis, however most of its revenue is coming from the Americas region as shown below in (Table 2) “number in millions, except percentages”:

Region 2012 2011
Americas $26,501 $25,015
Percentage of net sales 57.5% 57.9%
EMEA $12,075 $11,604
Percentage of net sales 26.2% 26.8%
APJC $7,485 $6,599
Percentage of net sales 16.3% 15.3%
Total $46,061 $43,218

 

Table 2. Cisco earnings per region.

 

Based on the IMF economic outlook report “May 2013” for the western hemisphere region, the average GDP growth for the Americas in 2012 was 2.85% and the average inflation rates in 2012 was 4.36%. The following economic context analysis for the Americas shows how Cisco’s financial position is aligned with the GDP growth and the inflation rates

Image

Figure 2. Cisco Americas revenue comparison

 

Cisco Americas sales revenue in 2012 has increased at a significantly faster rate than inflation and GDP growth. Cisco Americas sales revenue growth was around 6% which implies that there has been a real increase in the volume of products and services sold as opposed to simply charging customers more for the same level of sales.

Financial Ratios Analysis:

 

There are number of schemes for categorizing and analyzing ratios, this essay is focusing on a particular framework for classifying these ratios which classifies them as a measuring performance (P), efficiency (E), risk (R) and liquidity (L). This framework is referred to as PERL.

In addition to the PERL framework, some other ratios are very important to the shareholders in specific, these ratios include the following:

.       Earnings per share (E.P.S): The below graph “Figure 3” shows that Cisco’s earnings per share in 2012 was the highest in the past 5 years, usually the more earnings per share reflect the more dividends can be distributed to shareholders.

Image

Figure 3. Cisco EPS comparison.

 

.       Price/ Earnings (P/E) ratio: The following graph “Figure 4” shows the evolution of the P/E ration which measures the market price of the share as a proportion of the earnings per share.

Usually, the higher the P/E ratio, then the higher the expectations of the company’s future profitability, However it does not tell the full story as it has to be compared with the competitors…It’s obvious from the below graph that P/E ratio has fallen over time, while the above figures show that earnings steadily rise, it is a sign that price has not proportionately increased with earnings.

Image

Figure 4. Cisco P/E comparison

 

.       Dividend per share: This measures the amount of the dividends that the company actually paid to its shareholders, Cisco started to pay dividends in 2011.

Image

Measuring Performance:

 

Basically, the performance of Cisco business can measured by the efficiency by which it converts various financial inputs such as capital employed or sales turnover into profit. There are other less direct measures of performance that is out of this essay’s scope.

.       Margin ratio: This ratio was discussed under the margin analysis section above. It measures the amount of sales being captured by the firm as profit.

It’s important to add to the above profit margin analysis the operating cost to sales ratio, which seems to be enhanced in the last according to Figure 6.

Image

Figure 6. Cisco operating cost to sales.

 

.       Return on total capital employed (ROCE): It is the principle return measure that can be derived from the accounts. It measures the return of profit on all of the capital invested in the business including long-term loans, preference capital and equity.

.        

2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Long-term borrowing  16,297.00  16,234.00  12,188.00  10,295.00  6,393.00
Total equity  51,301.00  47,259.00  44,285.00  38,677.00  34,402.00
Profit before tax  10,159.00  7,825.00  9,415.00  7,693.00  10,255.00
ROCE 15% 12% 17% 16% 25%

 

Table 3. Cisco ROCE components.

Image

Figure 7. Cisco ROCE comparison.

 

Figure 7 reflects the same results in the above profit margin analysis in Figure 1, where it shows slight performance improvement in 2012 than in 2011 but still lower than what it used to be in 2008 and 2010.

Measuring Efficiency:

 

Less direct efficiency (E) measures can reflect how a business is performing. There are multiple ratios to measure efficiency of a company; this essay will mention only the Cost Efficiency Ratio.

.       Cost efficiency ratio (CER): Cost efficiency ratio measures the ratio of actual cost to predicted cost.

2011 2012 predicted 2012 actual CER
Cost of sale  $ 16,682.00 $ 17,779.39 $ 17,852.00  1.00
Net Operating expenses $ 18,862.00 $ 20,102.79 $ 18,144.00  0.90

 

Table 4. Cisco Cost Efficiency Ratio Calculation.

 

From the above Table 4, the CER calculations for Cisco shows that the cost of sale has not been improved from 2011 to 2012, where a clear improvement is shown in the operating costs.

Measuring Risk:

 

There are different types of risk rations that a stakeholder might consider important like market risk and firm-specific risk. This essay is focusing on financial risk and specifically the gearing ratio.

.       Gearing ratio: This ratio measures the relationship of long-term borrowing to the total capital employed invested in the business.

 

2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Long-term borrowing  16,297.00  16,234.00  12,188.00  10,295.00  6,393.00
Total equity  51,301.00  47,259.00  44,285.00  38,677.00  34,402.00
Gearing ratio 24% 26% 22% 21% 16%

 

Table 5. Cisco gearing ratio comparison.

Image

Figure 8. Cisco gearing ratio.

 

 

The above data from Table 5 and Figure 8 shows represent modest decrease in gearing in 2012 than in 2011, mostly brought about because the company’s increasing profitability is increasing the value of the owner’s equity in the balance sheet at a faster rate than the company’s increase in borrowing.

Measuring Liquidity:

 

Measuring Liquidity is important to reflect the company’s ability to cover its short-term liabilities using short-term resources.

.       Current asset ratio: This ratio reflects how the current inventories, receivables and cash can cover the short-term liabilities.

2012 2011 2010 2009 2008
Current Assets  $61,933.00  $57,231.00  $51,421.00  $44,177.00  $35,699.00
Current Liabilities  $17,731.00  $17,506.00  $19,233.00  $13,655.00  $13,858.00
CAR 3.49 3.27 2.67 3.24 2.58

 

Table 6. Cisco Current Asset Ratio Comparison.

Image

Figure 9. Cisco Current Asset Ratio Comparison.

 

The above Table 6 and Figure 9 show Cisco’s ability to cover the current liabilities, it is obvious that Cisco has huge amount of cash and current assets that make it capable to cover the current liabilities as well as re-investing some cash and distribute dividends.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References:

  • Bob Ryan (2008). Finance and accounting for business, second edition (chapter 7). Cangage Learning EMEA.
  • Cisco (2002) Cisco Undertakes the Largest IP Telephony Deployment in Industry History [online] available from

<http://www.cisco.com/web/about/ciscoitatwork/downloads/ciscoitatwork/pdf/cisco_ip_telephony.pdf >

  • Cisco (n.d) Visual Networking Index [online] available from

<http://www.cisco.com/en/US/netsol/ns827/networking_solutions_sub_solution.html#~usage >

  • Yahoo Finance (2013) Cisco Systems, Inc. Stock Chart [online] available from

<http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=CSCO+Interactive#symbol=csco;range=20080331,20100831;compare=;indicator=volume;charttype=area;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined;&gt;.

  • S-Cool (n.d) Shareholder Ratios [online] available from

< http://www.s-cool.co.uk/a-level/business-studies/ratio-analysis/revise-it/shareholders-ratios&gt;

  • IMF (2013) Regional Economic Outlook for Western Hemisphere [online] available from

< http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/reo/2013/whd/eng/pdf/wreo0513.pdf&gt;

  • Cisco (2008) Cisco Annual Report 2008 [online] available from

<http://www.cisco.com/web/about/ac49/ac20/downloads/annualreport/ar2008/pdf/cisco_ar2008_complete.pdf&gt;

  • Cisco (2009) Cisco Annual Report 2009 [online] available from

<http://www.cisco.com/assets/cdc_content_elements/docs/annualreports/media/2009-ar.pdf&gt;

  • Cisco (2010) Cisco Annual Report 2010 [online] available from

<https://materials.proxyvote.com/Approved/17275R/20100920/AR_67529/HTML2/default.htm&gt;

  • Cisco (2011) Cisco Annual Report 2011 [online] available from

<https://materials.proxyvote.com/Approved/17275R/20111010/AR_104291/HTML2/default.htm&gt;

  • Cisco (2012) Cisco Annual Report 2012 [online] available from

<https://materials.proxyvote.com/Approved/17275R/20120917/AR_142319/&gt;

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix:

 

Cisco Balance Sheet Comparison:

2012 Variance 2011 Variance 2010 Variance 2009 Variance 2008
Assets
Current Assets
Cash $9,799 27.9% $7,662 67.3% $4,581 -19.9% $5,718 10.2% $5,191
Financing Receivables, net $3,661 17.7% $3,111 35.1% $2,303 N/A $- $-
Investments $38,917 5.4% $36,923 4.7% $35,280 20.5% $29,283 39.2% $21,044
Accounts Receivable $4,369 -7.0% $4,698 -4.7% $4,929 55.1% $3,177 -16.9% $3,821
Inventory $1,663 11.9% $1,486 12.0% $1,327 23.6% $1,074 -13.0% $1,235
Deferred Tax Assets $2,294 -4.8% $2,410 13.4% $2,126 -8.4% $2,320 11.8% $2,075
Other Current Assets $1,230 30.7% $941 7.5% $875 -66.4% $2,605 11.7% $2,333
Total Current Assets $61,933 8.2% $57,231 11.3% $51,421 16.4% $44,177 23.7% $35,699
Investments $- $- $- $- $-
Property, Plant and Equipment
Equipment and Property $3,402 -13.1% $3,916 -0.6% $3,941 -2.5% $4,043 -2.6% $4,151
Property, Plant and Equipment – Net $3,402 -13.1% $3,916 -0.6% $3,941 -2.5% $4,043 -2.6% $4,151
Intangible Assets
Goodwill $16,998 1.1% $16,818 0.9% $16,674 29.0% $12,925 4.3% $12,392
Purchased Intangible Assets $1,959 -22.9% $2,541 -22.4% $3,274 92.4% $1,702 -18.5% $2,089
Total Intangible Assets $18,957 -2.1% $19,359 -3.0% $19,948 36.4% $14,627 1.0% $14,481
Other Assets $7,467 13.3% $6,589 13.2% $5,820 10.2% $5,281 19.9% $4,403
 
Total Assets $91,759 5.4% $87,095 7.4% $81,130 19.1% $68,128 16.0% $58,734

 

2012 Variance 2011 Variance 2010 Variance 2009 Variance 2008
Liabilities
Current Liabilities
Short-term Debt. $31 -94.7% $588 -81.0% $3,096 N/A $- $- $500
Accounts Payable $859 -1.9% $876 -2.1% $895 32.6% $675 -22.3% $869
Accrued Compensation $2,928 -7.4% $3,163 1.1% $3,129 23.4% $2,535 4.4% $2,428
Deffered Revenue $8,852 10.3% $8,025 4.7% $7,664 19.0% $6,438 3.9% $6,197
Taxes Payable $276 130.0% $120 33.3% $90 -45.8% $166 55.1% $107
Other Current Liabilities $4,785 1.1% $4,734 8.6% $4,359 13.5% $3,841 2.2% $3,757
Total Current Liabilities $17,731 1.3% $17,506 -9.0% $19,233 40.8% $13,655 -1.5% $13,858
Long Term Liabilities
Long-term Debt. $16,297 0.4% $16,234 33.2% $12,188 18.4% $10,295 61.0% $6,393
Other Long-term Liabilities $6,430 5.5% $6,096 12.4% $5,424 -1.4% $5,501 34.8% $4,081
Total Long Term Liabilities $22,727 1.8% $22,330 26.8% $17,612 11.5% $15,796 50.8% $10,474
Total Liabilities $40,458 1.6% $39,836 8.1% $36,845 25.1% $29,451 21.0% $24,332
Stockholders Equity
Common Stock $39,271 1.6% $38,648 2.3% $37,793 10.0% $34,344 2.5% $33,505
Retained Earnings $11,354 55.9% $7,284 24.5% $5,851 51.3% $3,868 3123.3% $120
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income $661 -48.9% $1,294 107.7% $623 43.2% $435 -40.2% $728
Total Stockholders Equity $51,286 8.6% $47,226 6.7% $44,267 14.5% $38,647 12.5% $34,353
Non Controlling Interest $15 -54.5% $33 83.3% $18 -40.0% $30 -38.8% $49
Total Equity $51,301 8.6% $47,259 6.7% $44,285 14.5% $38,677 12.4% $34,402
Total Liability & Stockholders Equity $91,759 5.4% $87,095 7.4% $81,130 19.1% $68,128 16.0% $58,734

 

One thought on “Cisco Systems’ Financial Analysis (2008 to 2012)”

Leave a comment